A NEW APPROACH FOR THE NUMERICAL ASSESSMENT OF FAILURE OF THE COMPOSITE DOVETAIL JOINT UNDER TENSILE LOADING

Abstract


This paper proposes and tests a new approach to assessing stress-strain states and determining failure regions of thick-walled tapered composite elements. The mesostructure features of composites, such as ply drops and resin pockets, are not explicitly considered in this approach. The constitutive model based on the multiphase finite element approach was extended to describe the three-dimensional stress-strain state. The model consisted of orthotropic linear-elastic and isotropic elastic-plastic sub-elements which simulate the properties of the fibres and matrix, respectively. The assumption of independence of the shear curve from the type of stress state was adopted to describe the nonlinear deformation response in the model. The calibration of the interlaminar nonlinear response of the constitutive model was performed using the test results of V-notched specimens under combined loading. Then, the verified model was used to determine the delamination load of the dovetail specimens. The delamination load of the dovetail specimens was estimated with the Nouthwestern (NU-Daniel) and the Hashin failure criteria. Finite element analysis of the influence of interlaminar strength and taper angle on the failure load of the dovetail specimens was performed. Based on the results obtained, we proposed the method for determining the rational parameters of the dovetail specimen. It was shown that the new approach could be effective for strength assessment and nonlinear behaviour analysis of tapered thick-walled composite structures at interlaminar shear strains up to 6%.

Full Text

The carbon fibre-reinforced plastics (CFRP) are considered to be an alternative to metals in elements of new generation aircraft, where weight is one of the critical parameters. Due to significant progress in manufacturing technologies, significant number of load-bearing elements are currently made of composites. In particular, wide-chord fan blades of foreign engines GEnx from General Electric, Rolls-Royce Advance and UltraFan families are made of CFRP [1]. This significantly reduces the weight of the blades and reduces the inertial and dynamic loads transmitted to other engine elements. Currently, composite materials are also widely used in the design of the fan of Russian aircraft engines PD-14 and PD-35 [2]. Dovetail joint is most often used to connect wide-chord fan blades with an engine rotor [3]. The composite dovetail joint is a thick-walled multilayer structure that is subjected to a complex multiaxial loading during operation. The composite dovetail joint may include various manufacturing defects, such as ply drops, warped layers, and resin pockets [4]. Due to these structural inhomogeneities and low interlaminar strength, tapered composite elements are prone to delamination [5]. At the same time, experimental data have shown that the through-thickness compression effect can significantly increase the interlaminar shear strength [6]. The combination of loads (transverse compression and interlaminar shear) leads to a complex nonlinear response, which is largely determined not by the brittle elastic fibre, but by the polymer matrix [6]. Thus, the assessment of the strength of a dovetail joint is a complex scientific and technical problem. A large number of computational and experimental studies are required to solve it [7]. There are two general approaches to predict the delamination load and the delamination growth. They are the strength of materials approach and the strain-energy-release-rate approach. According to the strength of materials approach, local stresses or strains are compared to the allowable material strength. Various failure criteria are used, for example, the maximum stress criterion, the NU-Daniel criteria [8-9], Christensen [10], Puck [11], Mohr-Coulomb [12], Hashin [13], etc. [14]. The criterion approach of maximum stresses has become widespread in engineering practice for solving this kind of problems [12-15] due to its simplicity. In [15, 20-21], rational reinforcement schemes were selected for mesoscale modelling of thick-walled composite elements. The authors did not explicitly take into account defects such as ply drops and resin pockets in these finite element models. In [21], a two-fold safety factor was obtained using the maximum stress criterion for the outlet guide vane under operating loads. In [22], the experimental results of the outlet guide vane tests under different loading types were compared with the numerical results. It was concluded that the numerical method [21] predicted a reliable assessment of the mechanical state of the composite vane. In [20], the analysis of the strength of the composite frame using the maximum stress criterion demonstrated a difference between the numerical and experimental failure load of 8%. However, the assessment of the strength using the maximum stress criterion under combined transverse compression/shear predicts a very conservative failure load [23]. The researchers [23] have shown that the NU-Daniel failure criterion predicts a higher delamination load, since the criterion considers the effect of through-thickness compression in the taper part of the dovetail joint. In this case, it is necessary to use, for example, the Hashin criterion [13], which considers the effect of tensile transverse stresses on the interlaminar strength for an adequate assessment of the strength in the thin part. It should be noted that the delamination load was determined without taking into account the actual nonlinear behaviour characteristic of thick-walled composites in the numerical models [15–23]. The alternative strain-energy-release-rate approach is based on fracture mechanics. It is used to predict the delamination growth. The laminate is assumed to fail when the available strain energy of a delamination crack in a ply interface exceeds the critical strain energy release rate for the material. Most researchers [4, 24-29] have predicted the delamination growth in tapered composite elements using virtual crack-closure technique (VCCT) or cohesive zone model (СZM). However, the authors considered the through-thickness compression effect only in some studies [4, 29]. In these studies, high-fidelity finite element simulation was used to describe the layered mesostructure of the composite. The finite element models included ply drops and resin pockets explicitly. Cohesive elements were used to analyse delamination in these models. Unfortunately, there is uncertainty in the parameters of the cohesive element adhesion strength [30-32] and the coefficient of the through-thickness compression effect [33-34] for such models. These discrepancies can lead to an error in determining the delamination region, while the peak delamination load will be significantly underestimated [4]. The researchers [4, 29] have shown that the parameters of cohesive contacts largely determine the failure type and the failure force of severely tapered specimens. It was shown that a good correlation with the experiment can be achieved by varying the parameters of cohesive pairs within the limits known in the literature. In addition, the boundary conditions introduce significant uncertainty into the calculation results. In [4], the authors assessed the effect of the friction coefficient between the dovetail specimen and the disk on the ultimate failure load. Increasing the friction coefficient from 0.1 to 0.3 leads to the change in the failure load by 20%. It is worth noting that the matrix properties provided by the manufacturer are used when simulating resin pockets in these high-fidelity models. However, authors in [35] showed that the actual in-situ properties of the resin pocket differ significantly from those of the epoxy resin obtained on standard specimens. The disadvantages of the high-fidelity finite element models combined with the high complexity of their preparation and the duration of calculations make them too difficult for practical engineering calculations of real structures. This is especially critical for the initial design stages when engineers need to select rational reinforcement schemes and assess their impact on the strength and stiffness of the entire structure. For such tasks, it is advisable to develop low-parameter numerical models using the strength approach that considers the features of nonlinear deformation and failure inherent in tapered thick-walled composite elements. To describe the nonlinear response of composites, various deformation models, based on the approaches of nonlinear elasticity, progressive damage accumulation and elastoplasticity were developed [36]. The significant number of studies [37-43] are related to the description of the in-plane nonlinear response of composites. The algorithm for describing the interlaminar nonlinear response was presented in the papers [44-45]. The researches [44] developed a low-parameter constitutive model in ABAQUS VUMAT for describing the interlaminar nonlinear response of unidirectional glass- and carbon-fibre reinforced plastics. It was shown that the nonlinear response can be approximated by the Ramberg-Osgood power law under pure shear. Similarly, the interlaminar nonlinear response was described in the papers [4, 29] when assessing the strength of tapered thick-walled composite elements. In these studies, the parameters of the approximation of the nonlinear response were determined from the pure shear deformation curves. However, the interlaminar strength and nonlinear response of thick-walled composites under combined loading differ significantly from those under pure shear [6]. The multiphase finite element (mFEA) approach [46] demonstrated good predictive capabilities of the in-plane nonlinear response fabric composites under combined loading [47]. A small number of identifiable parameters makes this model attractive for practical calculations of large structures. In this study, the mFEA approach was modified and expanded to describe the fabric composite interlaminar nonlinear response under combined loading. Model elastic parameters were identified based on standard tensile, compression, and shear test methods. The interlaminar nonlinear response was calibrated based on the test results of V-notched specimens under combined loading. Finally, numerical calculations were performed to assess the static strength of the dovetail joint. The influence of such factors as interlaminar strength and taper angle of the dovetail specimen on the failure load was also studied.

About the authors

K. A Guseinov

South Ural State University (National Research University), Chelyabinsk, Russian Federation

O. A Kudryavtsev

South Ural State University (National Research University), Chelyabinsk, Russian Federation

S. B Sapozhnikov

South Ural State University (National Research University), Chelyabinsk, Russian Federation

References

  1. Kutilin S.G., Kozhina T.D. Osobennosti tekhnologicheskogo processa izgotovleniya detalej kompressorov aviacionnyh GTD iz polimernyh kompozicionnyh materialov [Singularities of polymeric composite materials in an aircraft turbine engine compressor details manufacturing technological process]. Vestnik Rybinskoj gosudarstvennoj aviacionnoj tekhnologicheskoj akademii im. PA Solov`eva. 2014, no. 1, pp. 48-54
  2. Timoshkov P.N., Kolobkov A.S., Kurnosov A.O., Goncharov V.A. Prepregi na osnove rasplavnyx svyazuyushchih i PKM novogo pokoleniya na ih osnove dlya izdelij aviacionnoj tekhniki [Prepregs based on melt binders and new generation PCMs based on them for aviation equipment]. POLIMERNYE KOMPOZICIONNYE MATERIALY I PROIZVODSTVENNYE TEXNOLOGII NOVOGO POKOLENIYA. 2021, pp. 7-20
  3. Inozemtsev A.A., Nikhamkin M.Sh., Sandratskii V.L. Osnovy konstruirovaniia aviatsionnykh dvigatelei i energeticheskikh ustanovok. Vol. 2 [Design principles of aircraft engines and power plants]. Moscow: Mashinostroenie, 2008. 368 p
  4. Noh H. K., Go M. S., Lim J. H., Choi Y. H., Kim J. G. Numerical modeling and experimental validation of lamina fracture and progressive delamination in composite dovetail specimens under tensile loading. Composite Structures. 2023, Vol. 325, pp. 117578
  5. Helmy S., Hoa S. V. Tensile fatigue behavior of tapered glass fiber reinforced epoxy composites containing nanoclay. Composites Science and Technology. 2014, Vol. 102, pp. 10-19
  6. DeTeresa S.J., Freeman D.C., Groves S.E. The effects of through-thickness compression on the interlaminar shear response of laminated fiber composites. Journal of composite materials. 2004, Vol. 38(8), pp. 681-697
  7. Anoshkin A.N., Zuiko V.Yu., Shipunov G.S., Tretyakov A.A. Technologies and problems of composite materials mechanics for production of outlet guide vane for aircraft jet engine. PNRPU Mechanics Bulletin. 2014, no. 4, pp. 5-44
  8. Daniel I. M. Failure of composite materials. Strain. 2007, Vol. 43(1), pp. 4-12
  9. Daniel I. M., Luo J. J., Schubel P. M. Three-dimensional characterization of textile composites. Composites Part B: Engineering. 2008, Vol. 39(1), pp. 13-19
  10. Christensen R. M., DeTeresa S.J. Delamination failure investigation for out-of-plane loading in laminates. Journal of composite materials. 2004, Vol. 38 (24), pp. 2231-2238
  11. Puck A., Schürmann H. Failure analysis of FRP laminates by means of physically based phenomenological models. Composites science and technology. 2002, Vol. 62(12-13), pp. 1633-1662
  12. Chatterjee S.N. A Coulomb-Mohr type criterion for matrix mode failure in a lamina. ASTM special technical publication. 1997, Vol. 1242, pp. 237-256
  13. Hashin Z. Fatigue failure criteria for unidirectional fiber composites. Journal of Applied Mechanics. 1980, Vol. 47(4), pp. 329-334
  14. Hinton M. Failure criteria in fibre reinforced polymer composites: the world-wide failure exercise. Elsevier. 2004
  15. Grinev M.A., Anoshkin A.N., Pisarev P.V., Zuiko V.Yu., Shipunov G.S. CAD/CAE modelling of mechanical behavior of composite outlet guide vane for aircraft jet engine. PNRPU Mechanics Bulletin. 2015, no. 3, pр. 38-51
  16. Anoshkin A.N., Tashkinov A.A., Gritsevich A.M. Prediction of the bearing capacity of composite flanges for aircraft-engine casing parts. Mechanics of composite materials. 1997, Vol. 33(3), pp. 255-262
  17. Anoshkin A.N., Rudakov M.V., Straumit I.S., Grinev M.A. Modeling the mechanical tests of composite flange sample-segment from aircraft engine cover. Izvestia of RAS SamSC. 2011, Vol. 13(1-2), pp. 283–288
  18. Anoshkin A.N., Rudakov M.V., Straumit I.S., Shustova E.N. Raschet NDS i otsenka prochnosti kompozitnogo flantsa stekloplastikovogo kozhukha aviatsionnogo gazoturbinnogo dvigatelia [Stress-strain state and strength calculation of composite flange for aircraft engine casing]. Vestnik Ufimskogo gosudarstvennogo aviatsionnogo tekhnologicheskogo universiteta. 2011, Vol. 15, no. 1 (41), pp. 67-75
  19. Potrahov N.N., Anoshkin A.N., Zuiko V.Y., Osokin V.M., Pisarev P.V., Pelenev K.A. Numerical and experimental study of composite bulkhead partition strength with in-situ x-ray monitoring. PNRPU Mechanics Bulletin. 2017, no. 1, pp. 118-133
  20. Anoshkin A.N., Zuiko V.Y., Pelenev K.A., Pisarev P.V., Shipunov G.S. Numerical simulation for development of methodology of stress-strain state control of composite bulkhead for aviation application with the usage of FBG sensors. PNRPU Mechanics Bulletin. 2018, no. 4, pp. 47-57
  21. Grinev M.A., Anoshkin A.N., Pisarev P.V., Zuiko V.Y., Shipunov G.S. Stress-strain analysis and strength prediction of composite outlet guide vane for aircraft jet engine. PNRPU Mechanics Bulletin. 2015, no. 4, 293-307
  22. Shipunov G.S. Raschetno-ehksperimental'naya ocenka staticheskoj prochnosti lopatki spryamlyayushchego apparata iz polimernyh kompozicionnyh materialov: dissertaciya na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni k.t.n: 01.02.04 / Perm' 2016. – 136 p
  23. Guseinov K., Kudryavtsev O. A., Sapozhnikov S. B. Effectiveness of 2-D and 3-D modelling of dovetail joint of composite fan blade for choosing rational reinforcement schemes. PNRPU Mechanics Bulletin. 2021, no. 1, pp. 5-11
  24. Cui W., Wisnom M. R., Jones M. Effect of step spacing on delamination of tapered laminates. Composites science and technology. 1994, Vol. 52(1), pp. 39-46
  25. Wisnom M. R., Dixon R., Hill G. Delamination in asymmetrically tapered composites loaded in tension. Composite structures. 1996, Vol. 35(3), pp. 309-322
  26. Gan K. W., Allegri G., Hallett S. R. A simplified layered beam approach for predicting ply drop delamination in thick composite laminates. Materials Design. 2016, Vol. 108, pp. 570-580
  27. Vidyashankar B. R., Murty A. V. K. Analysis of laminates with ply drops. Composites science and technology. 2001, Vol. 61(5), pp. 749-758
  28. Meirinhos G., Rocker J., Cabanac J. P., Barrau J. J. Tapered laminates under static and fatigue tension loading. Composites science and technology. 2002, Vol. 62(4), pp. 597-603
  29. Zhang B., Kawashita L. F., Jones M. I., Lander J. K., Hallett S. R. An experimental and numerical investigation into damage mechanisms in tapered laminates under tensile loading. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing. 2020, Vol. 133, pp. 105862
  30. Hallett S. R., Green B. G., Jiang W. G., Wisnom M. R. An experimental and numerical investigation into the damage mechanisms in notched composites. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing. 2009, Vol. 40(5), pp. 613-624
  31. Mukhopadhyay S., Jones M. I., Hallett S. R. Compressive failure of laminates containing an embedded wrinkle; experimental and numerical study. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing. 2015, Vol. 73, pp. 132-142
  32. Charalambous G., Allegri G., Lander J. K., Hallett S. R. A cut-ply specimen for the mixed-mode fracture toughness and fatigue characterisation of FRPs. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing. 2015, Vol. 74, pp. 77-87
  33. Li X., Hallett S. R., Wisnom M. R. Predicting the effect of through-thickness compressive stress on delamination using interface elements. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing. 2008, Vol. 39(2), pp. 218-230
  34. Zou Z., Lee H. A cohesive zone model taking account of the effect of through-thickness compression. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing. 2017, Vol. 98, pp. 90-98
  35. Chevalier J., Camanho P. P., Lani F., Pardoen T. Multi-scale characterization and modelling of the transverse compression response of unidirectional carbon fiber reinforced epoxy. Composite Structures. 2019, Vol. 209, pp. 160-176
  36. Fallahi H., Taheri-Behrooz F., Asadi A. Nonlinear mechanical response of polymer matrix composites: a review. Polymer Reviews. 2020, Vol. 60(1), pp. 42–85
  37. Chang F. K., Chang K. Y. A progressive damage model for laminated composites containing stress concentrations. Journal of composite materials. 1987, Vol. 21(9), pp. 834-855
  38. Ladeveze P., LeDantec E. Damage modelling of the elementary ply for laminated composites. Composites science and technology. 1992, Vol. 43(3), pp. 257-267
  39. Matzenmiller A., Lubliner J., Taylor R. L. A constitutive model for anisotropic damage in fiber-composites. Mechanics of materials. 1995, Vol. 20(2), pp. 125-152
  40. Laux T., Gan K. W., Dulieu-Barton J. M., Thomsen O. T. A simple nonlinear constitutive model based on non-associative plasticity for UD composites: Development and calibration using a Modified Arcan Fixture. International Journal of Solids and Structures. 2019, Vol. 162, pp. 135-147
  41. Cho J., Fenner J., Werner B., Daniel I. M. A constitutive model for fiber-reinforced polymer composites. Journal of composite materials. 2010, Vol. 44(26), pp. 3133-3150
  42. Jang J., Jeon S. Y., Choi J. H., Shim W., Cho J.M., Yoon S.J., Choi C. H., Yu W. R. Mechanical analysis of fiber-reinforced plastics using an elastoplastic-damage constitutive equation considering asymmetric material behaviour. Composite Structures. 2021, Vol. 272, pp. 114268
  43. Fedulov B. N., Fedorenko A. N., Kantor M. M., Lomakin E. Failure analysis of laminated composites based on degradation parameters. Meccanica. 2018, Vol. 53, pp. 359-372
  44. Makeev A., Ignatius C., He Y., Shonkwiler B. A test method for assessment of shear properties of thick composites. Journal of composite materials. 2009, Vol. 43(25), pp. 3091-3105
  45. Makeev A., He Y., Carpentier P., Shonkwiler B. A method for measurement of multiple constitutive properties for composite materials. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing. 2012, Vol. 43(12), pp. 2199-2210
  46. Sapozhnikov S. B., Guseynov K. A., Zhikharev M. V. Multiphase Fea-Approach for Non-Linear Deformation Prediction and Fibre-Reinforced Plastics Failure. Mechanics of Composite Materials. 2023, Vol. 59(2), pp. 283-298
  47. Guseinov K. A., Leshkov E. V., Kudryavtsev O. A., Olivenko N. A., Sapozhnikov S. B. Ocenka primenimosti modelej deformirovaniya na osnove edinoj krivoj sdviga dlya opisaniya nelinejnogo otklika tkanevogo polimernogo kompozita pri slozhnom napryazhennom sostoyanii [Two constitutive models based on the unified shear curve to predict a nonlinear response of fabric carbon fiber-reinforced plastics in the 2D stress state]. Physical mesomecanics. 2025, Vol. 28(1), pp. 66-83
  48. Barbero E.J. Introduction to composite materials design, 2nd ed., CRC Press. 2011, 520 p
  49. Lee H. H. Finite Element Simulations with ANSYS Workbench 2023: Theory, Applications, Case Studies. SDC publications. 2023, 614 p
  50. Guseinov K., Kudryavtsev O., Bezmelnitsyn A., Sapozhnikov S. Determination of interlaminar shear properties of fibre-reinforced composites under biaxial loading: A new experimental approach. Polymers. 2022, Vol. 14(13), pp. 2575
  51. Abot J. L., Daniel I. M. Through-thickness mechanical characterization of woven fabric composites. Journal of Composite Materials. 2004, Vol. 38(7), pp. 543-553
  52. Raskutin A.E. Rossijskie polimernye kompozicionnye materialy novogo pokoleniya, ih osvoenie i vnedrenie v perspektivnyh razrabatyvaemyh konstrukciyah. Aviacionnye materialy i tekhnologii [Russian polymer composite materials of new generation, their exploitation and implementation in advanced developed constructions]. 2017, no: S, pp. 349-367
  53. Leshkov E.V., Sapozhnikov S.B. Modeling the nonlinear deformation and damage of carbon-aramid fabric composites in tension. Mechanics of Composite Materials. 2020, Vol. 56, pp. 591–600
  54. Mishurov K.S., Mishkin S.I. Vliyanie vneshnej sredy` na svojstva ugleplastika VKU-39 [The influence of the external environment on the properties of CFRP VKU-39]. Trudy` VIAM. 2016, Vol. 12 (48), pp. 55-6

Statistics

Views

Abstract - 54

PDF (Russian) - 27

Cited-By


PlumX


Copyright (c) 2025 Guseinov K.A., Kudryavtsev O.A., Sapozhnikov S.B.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies